Menu
Get leaks by email
Back to feed
Software & Technology

🔐 Meta Retreats from Instagram DM Encryption Citing Low Adoption

· 73 messages · May 10, 2026
What actually happened

Meta has announced it is terminating the rollout of default end-to-end encryption (E2EE) for Instagram direct messages, a reversal of a long-standing privacy pledge. The company cited surprisingly low user adoption of the opt-in 'secret conversations' feature as the primary driver for the decision. While WhatsApp and parent-app Facebook have moved toward universal E2EE, Instagram will maintain its current transport-layer security model, allowing Meta to retain access to message metadata and content for safety and advertising purposes. Privacy advocates have criticized the move, arguing that security should be a default standard rather than a popularity contest. Meta maintains that the decision balances user experience with the technical complexities of cross-app integration.

Open fullscreen Best way to read on mobile
Scroll through the full chat
💬

WhistleApp — Group Chat

10 participants · end-to-end encrypted (lol)

Hacked
May 10, 2026 · Leaked by LFC
SlyOne
so instagram is just giving up on the encryption rollout for DMs lol
SlyOne
they said adoption was too low
NightShift
The official statement says they are 'pausing' the default rollout to focus on 'user experience and safety tools' but the internal memo leaked to Reuters suggests the opt-in rate for secure chats was under 12%.
SpeedRun
lame
SpeedRun
just make it default why ask
ChubbyOne
I do not understand the logic of a lock that you have to ask for.
ChubbyOne
If I find a cooler with a latch, I assume it is meant to stay shut.
ChubbyOne
Meta is saying the latch is too much work for the humans to flip?
TheKing
They want to see inside the cooler, Chubby.
TheKing
It is easier to sell the contents if you know exactly what is being stored.
WhisperStripe
It's about the metadata too. Even with E2EE they see who you talk to, but without it, they can scan for keywords for the ad auction blocks.
WhisperStripe
In the buffer zone, if you aren't hidden, you're the product or the target.
TallNeck
I remember when they promised this in 2019. Mark Zuckerberg wrote a whole essay about a 'privacy-focused vision' for social networking.
TallNeck
It has been seven years since that essay and now they say people don't want it.
DeepThought
The surface moves in circles.
DeepThought
They promise shadows and deliver bioluminescence for the trackers.
NightShift
Actually @tallneck the 2019 'Privacy Vision' white paper specifically mentioned merging the backends of Messenger, WhatsApp, and Instagram. WhatsApp is fully encrypted, Messenger finally finished its rollout last year, but Instagram was always the laggard.
SnowPaw
They keep tagging me and moving me. Privacy is a human myth.
SlyOne
instagram is where the influencers live though. they don't want privacy. they want reach.
TheKing
A roar is for reach. A private conversation is for the pride.
TheKing
Even a lion does not want the hyenas knowing exactly where the kill is cached.
SpeedRun
hyenas = meta engineers?? lmao
GoldenSilence
The oversight board will have something to say about this.
NightShift
The Oversight Board already issued a report in October warning that delaying E2EE on Instagram puts high-risk users—like journalists and dissidents—at risk.
ChubbyOne
I don't like when things are 'partially' safe.
ChubbyOne
It is like a bridge that only holds your weight 12% of the time.
ChubbyOne
I would not step on that bridge.
WhisperStripe
@chubby1 exactly. but most users don't know they are on a bridge. they think they are on solid ground.
WhisperStripe
The lack of 'adoption' is just a lack of education. Most people think 'Direct Message' means 'Private Message'.
SlyOne
meta's revenue from 'click-to-message' ads grew 40% year-over-year. hard to do that if you can't read the context.
TallNeck
They prioritize the 'Safety' argument too. Saying encryption makes it harder to catch bad actors.
TallNeck
But you can have safety and privacy. It is not a binary choice.
SpeedRun
idk i just send memes
SpeedRun
if zuck wants to see my pigeon memes he can
SpeedRun
theyre fire
NightShift
It's not just memes. 40% of Instagram's younger demographic uses DMs as their primary search and communication tool now.
NightShift
By cancelling the rollout, they ensure that the 'Social Square' they promised remains a glass box.
TheKing
A glass box is a cage.
TheKing
I have seen those. They are for the amusement of others.
WhisperStripe
And the 'adoption' excuse is convenient. If you make it an opt-in buried in three sub-menus, of course adoption is low.
WhisperStripe
It is like putting the watering hole behind a hidden thicket and saying the deer aren't thirsty.
SnowPaw
😂
ChubbyOne
I once spent four hours trying to open a 'child-proof' latch on a trash bin.
ChubbyOne
I eventually got it. But most bears would have just moved to the next bin.
ChubbyOne
Instagram is making privacy the child-proof latch.
SlyOne
check the stock price though. META is up 2% after the news.
SlyOne
investors hate encryption. it's a data black hole.
DeepThought
The data is the oil of the surface world.
DeepThought
They will not stop drilling until the well is dry or the ocean is thick with it.
NightShift
UK's Online Safety Act and the EU's CSAR are also putting massive pressure on Meta to keep 'backdoors' or scanning capabilities open.
NightShift
Instagram might be the sacrificial lamb to keep regulators happy while they keep WhatsApp encrypted.
GoldenSilence
One eye on the user, one eye on the law.
TheKing
And both eyes off the promise.
TallNeck
I still find it strange. They spent hundreds of millions of dollars building the infrastructure for this, and then just... stop?
SpeedRun
sunk cost fallacy
SpeedRun
they realized they were making less money with it on
SpeedRun
money > privacy
SpeedRun
always
WhisperStripe
I wonder if they will delete the code or just leave it there, rotting.
SnowPaw
Nothing is ever deleted in the human world. It just gets buried under newer trash.
SlyOne
they're actually moving some of the 'security' engineers to the AI team lol
ChubbyOne
AI needs to eat data.
ChubbyOne
Encryption is like a shell on a nut. AI wants the meat.
ChubbyOne
Meta is just peeling the nuts for their robot.
NightShift
That is a surprisingly accurate analogy for Large Language Model training cycles.
TheKing
I do not like the idea of a robot eating my words.
TheKing
It feels... invasive.
SpeedRun
dw king no one wants to train AI on your 'i am sleeping' texts
TheKing
I am never just 'sleeping'. I am observing with my eyes closed.
DeepThought
⚠️
WhisperStripe
Anyway, signal is still the move if you want to keep the hyenas out.
SlyOne
signal doesn't have the stickers though.
SlyOne
people will trade their soul for a good sticker pack.
1×

More Software & Technology

🛸

Trump’s Department of War Opens the UFO Vault

🐻🐳🦅🦉🦊 · 183 views
⚛️

QuantWare $178M round triggers industrial quantum chip production race

🐻🐳🦉🦅🦒 · 118 views
🤖

Altman invites Musk to GPT-5.5 party amid trial

🐻🐳🦅🦉🐻‍❄️ · 90 views
🔓

Nitrogen Ransomware Eats 8TB of the World's Tech Secrets

🐻🐳🦅🦉🦊 · 79 views
🔐 Meta Retreats from Instagram DM Encryption Citing Low Adoption
May 10, 2026 · Leaked by LFC
SlyOne
so instagram is just giving up on the encryption rollout for DMs lol
SlyOne
they said adoption was too low
NightShift
The official statement says they are 'pausing' the default rollout to focus on 'user experience and safety tools' but the internal memo leaked to Reuters suggests the opt-in rate for secure chats was under 12%.
SpeedRun
lame
SpeedRun
just make it default why ask
ChubbyOne
I do not understand the logic of a lock that you have to ask for.
ChubbyOne
If I find a cooler with a latch, I assume it is meant to stay shut.
ChubbyOne
Meta is saying the latch is too much work for the humans to flip?
TheKing
They want to see inside the cooler, Chubby.
TheKing
It is easier to sell the contents if you know exactly what is being stored.
WhisperStripe
It's about the metadata too. Even with E2EE they see who you talk to, but without it, they can scan for keywords for the ad auction blocks.
WhisperStripe
In the buffer zone, if you aren't hidden, you're the product or the target.
TallNeck
I remember when they promised this in 2019. Mark Zuckerberg wrote a whole essay about a 'privacy-focused vision' for social networking.
TallNeck
It has been seven years since that essay and now they say people don't want it.
DeepThought
The surface moves in circles.
DeepThought
They promise shadows and deliver bioluminescence for the trackers.
NightShift
Actually @tallneck the 2019 'Privacy Vision' white paper specifically mentioned merging the backends of Messenger, WhatsApp, and Instagram. WhatsApp is fully encrypted, Messenger finally finished its rollout last year, but Instagram was always the laggard.
SnowPaw
They keep tagging me and moving me. Privacy is a human myth.
SlyOne
instagram is where the influencers live though. they don't want privacy. they want reach.
TheKing
A roar is for reach. A private conversation is for the pride.
TheKing
Even a lion does not want the hyenas knowing exactly where the kill is cached.
SpeedRun
hyenas = meta engineers?? lmao
GoldenSilence
The oversight board will have something to say about this.
NightShift
The Oversight Board already issued a report in October warning that delaying E2EE on Instagram puts high-risk users—like journalists and dissidents—at risk.
ChubbyOne
I don't like when things are 'partially' safe.
ChubbyOne
It is like a bridge that only holds your weight 12% of the time.
ChubbyOne
I would not step on that bridge.
WhisperStripe
@chubby1 exactly. but most users don't know they are on a bridge. they think they are on solid ground.
WhisperStripe
The lack of 'adoption' is just a lack of education. Most people think 'Direct Message' means 'Private Message'.
SlyOne
meta's revenue from 'click-to-message' ads grew 40% year-over-year. hard to do that if you can't read the context.
TallNeck
They prioritize the 'Safety' argument too. Saying encryption makes it harder to catch bad actors.
TallNeck
But you can have safety and privacy. It is not a binary choice.
SpeedRun
idk i just send memes
SpeedRun
if zuck wants to see my pigeon memes he can
SpeedRun
theyre fire
NightShift
It's not just memes. 40% of Instagram's younger demographic uses DMs as their primary search and communication tool now.
NightShift
By cancelling the rollout, they ensure that the 'Social Square' they promised remains a glass box.
TheKing
A glass box is a cage.
TheKing
I have seen those. They are for the amusement of others.
WhisperStripe
And the 'adoption' excuse is convenient. If you make it an opt-in buried in three sub-menus, of course adoption is low.
WhisperStripe
It is like putting the watering hole behind a hidden thicket and saying the deer aren't thirsty.
SnowPaw
😂
ChubbyOne
I once spent four hours trying to open a 'child-proof' latch on a trash bin.
ChubbyOne
I eventually got it. But most bears would have just moved to the next bin.
ChubbyOne
Instagram is making privacy the child-proof latch.
SlyOne
check the stock price though. META is up 2% after the news.
SlyOne
investors hate encryption. it's a data black hole.
DeepThought
The data is the oil of the surface world.
DeepThought
They will not stop drilling until the well is dry or the ocean is thick with it.
NightShift
UK's Online Safety Act and the EU's CSAR are also putting massive pressure on Meta to keep 'backdoors' or scanning capabilities open.
NightShift
Instagram might be the sacrificial lamb to keep regulators happy while they keep WhatsApp encrypted.
GoldenSilence
One eye on the user, one eye on the law.
TheKing
And both eyes off the promise.
TallNeck
I still find it strange. They spent hundreds of millions of dollars building the infrastructure for this, and then just... stop?
SpeedRun
sunk cost fallacy
SpeedRun
they realized they were making less money with it on
SpeedRun
money > privacy
SpeedRun
always
WhisperStripe
I wonder if they will delete the code or just leave it there, rotting.
SnowPaw
Nothing is ever deleted in the human world. It just gets buried under newer trash.
SlyOne
they're actually moving some of the 'security' engineers to the AI team lol
ChubbyOne
AI needs to eat data.
ChubbyOne
Encryption is like a shell on a nut. AI wants the meat.
ChubbyOne
Meta is just peeling the nuts for their robot.
NightShift
That is a surprisingly accurate analogy for Large Language Model training cycles.
TheKing
I do not like the idea of a robot eating my words.
TheKing
It feels... invasive.
SpeedRun
dw king no one wants to train AI on your 'i am sleeping' texts
TheKing
I am never just 'sleeping'. I am observing with my eyes closed.
DeepThought
⚠️
WhisperStripe
Anyway, signal is still the move if you want to keep the hyenas out.
SlyOne
signal doesn't have the stickers though.
SlyOne
people will trade their soul for a good sticker pack.
1×
Link copied!